Best of
Best Italian restaurants in the West Loop, Chicago
The West Loop carries one of the higher concentrations of Italian restaurants in Chicago, with everything from a Roman-style pizza counter to a wine-bar trattoria to a multi-room red-sauce destination. Every pick below links to its full business page.
Trattorias and wine bars
Smaller-format Italian — pasta, pizza, and substantial wine programs.
Full-service Italian
Bigger rooms and broader Italian menus.
- Monteverde Open now Sarah Grueneberg's Madison Street restaurant blending Italian tradition with global influences. Pasta is made fresh on-site; cited as one of the city's top Italian rooms.1020-1022 W Madison St 1, Chicago, IL, 60607
- Bar Siena Open now Italian restaurant on West Randolph — pizzas, pastas, and a large dining room.832 W Randolph St 1 & 2, Chicago, IL, 60607
- Formento's Nonna's Open now B. Hospitality Co.'s Italian Steakhouse on West Randolph (est. 2015) — Formento's main dining room plus Nonna's Pizza & Sandwiches sister concept for grab-and-go.917-923 W Randolph St, Chicago, IL, 60607
- Loft Lucia Open now Italian restaurant on West Lake Street.1-9 N Carpenter St 3 & 4, Chicago, IL, 60607
- Labriola Italian Open now Italian restaurant from the Labriola Bakery family.854-856 W Fulton Market, Chicago, IL, 60607
Show 3 more
- Rose Mary Open now Italian and Croatian restaurant on West Randolph from Top Chef winner Joe Flamm — "Adriatic drinking food" with a seasonal, rustic menu.932 W Fulton Market, Chicago, IL, 60607
- Gioia Open now Gioia Ristorante e Pastificio at 1133 W Randolph — Italian restaurant and in-house pasta shop at the western end of Restaurant Row. House-made fresh pastas, antipasti, mains, and a substantial Italian wine list across multiple connected dining rooms.
- Labriola Italian Specialties Open now Labriola Italian Specialties at 852 W Fulton Market — DoughBoy Restaurant Group's Italian restaurant and specialty market, opened April 2026 in the former Kuma's Corner space. House-made pasta, artisan pizzas (with a late-night walk-up slice window), Sicilian cannoli, and spumoni.
Fresh-pasta and counter-format
Fast-casual Italian focused on handmade pasta.
Pizza specialists
Italian places where pizza is the headline.
Frequently asked questions
- Where is the best Italian food in the West Loop, Chicago?
- There's no single answer — for a wine-bar trattoria, Bar Tutto. For a red-sauce big-group destination at an Italian Steakhouse, Formento's & Nonna's. For Roman pizza by the slice, Bonci. For modern Italian with handmade pasta, Alla Vita.
- Is there authentic Italian in the West Loop?
- Bonci is the American flagship of Roman-pizza maker Gabriele Bonci, with recipes brought from Rome. The other Italian restaurants on this list are Italian-American to varying degrees — most are Chicago-owned and lean modern Italian rather than strictly regional.
- Where can I get pasta in the West Loop?
- Monteverde is the most-mentioned pasta kitchen across the published Chicago guides we track; Alla Vita and Bar Tutto are our other pasta-focused picks. Bar Siena and Formento's also carry substantial pasta menus. Most full-service Italian restaurants on this list serve handmade pastas.
- Is there Italian fine dining in the West Loop?
- Alla Vita and Formento's are the higher-end Italian-specific picks in the West Loop; for full tasting-menu fine dining (not strictly Italian), see Smyth. West Loop Italian otherwise skews to "modern neighborhood Italian" — solid wine programs, polished service, but not the strict fine-dining-only format.
- Where can I get Italian wine in the West Loop?
- Bar Tutto leans heavily Italian in its wine program. La Serre / Bar La Rue is French-focused but stocks Italian bottles. Most full-service Italian restaurants on this list carry substantial Italian wine lists.
Most recent pick verified 5 days ago. Some picks may be older — the date reflects whichever pick on this page was checked most recently.